Krieger vs shilen vs bartlein. com Or chat in our forum at http://forum.

Krieger vs shilen vs bartlein I have been able to work up loads in that 3/4 MOA range without a ton of trouble. Just bought two more and now that makes 6 Bartleins in a row. Nov 18, 2014 · Note: Although most of the contours dimensions are the same among all the manufacturers, that might not always be the case. I have a Bartlein barrel in my 30-06 and it shoots great and cleans well. Lots of guys running savage prefits already and getting good results. I have had great luck with both. Consistent sub MOA all day long for 5 shot groups. Krieger is still the top of the top for me. Sep 15, 2013 · I'd easily take a Krieger, Bartlein, Brux, Obermeyer for cut barrels or a Hart, Shilen, Broughton, or Lilja for buttoned tubes. All three are excellent barrels. 625 at 24" continued taper. Have several Bartlein but never tried a Brux. My question is, are the Shilen, Benchmark, Brux etc. 5", while for the heavy varmint (#9) it's 5. Any recommendations are appreciated. 5x47 had one rock creek . , Bartlein $325. Criterion vs Wilson Combat . It was GM, Bartlein, Benchmark, Krieger and Lilja. 5 grendel's. Apr 9, 2014 · I have tried to buy a cut barrel (Bartlein or Krieger) however the ONLY two viable choices currently available in the country are: - Lothar Walter Palma Match (Stainless Steel LW50) - Shilen Select Match (Stainless Steel 416) Both have pretty much the same contours, are lapped and have a c. Once the barrels are made with that degree of precision, individual barrel differences will be more important than Kreiger vs. My above comment was based on personal experience, but there are other good barrel makers out there. I do not have any experience with Krieger barrels but I do with the Shilen and Muller. Same contour, length, muzzle threading, chamber and gunsmith. Velocity drop shows up quickly in performance. Shilen select match test. May 17, 2023 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". 5" and CLE 1:7. that much better than the Jun 6, 2019 · Knowing both Krieger and Bartlein people are reading and responding does not intimidate me. Nov 20, 2008 · In a tactical rig I would go with the match shilen instead of the select because you will never see the accuracy difference in a tactical rifle. In general a good Bartlein and a good Krieger will (properly tuned, chambered and fitted) will not show you any difference. Which takes me back to crown ridge. Just thinking about a new barrel. The Keystone is better than both CLE’s. The market is awash in premium quality barrels. Are the barrel and threads on the receiver going to be the same as the Shilen or am I going to have to remove my current barrel and send those specs in to have them cut to match up? 2. Jun 6, 2019 · I normally use Krieger barrels but have a couple of Lilja barrels. Jan 5, 2019 · Krieger Barrels had another strong showing, with 10% of these shooters using one of their barrels. That said, Pac-Nor built many good shooting rifles in past - and Hart did one, but I had some issues w/them, and would not do biz again. I would HIGHLY suggest a Bartlein or Brux over a Shilen any day. 24 inch Lilja on top and my present 20 inch CLE/Bartlein on the bottom. Current barrel is 26" long 1-14 twist. Thread starter surgeon260; Start date Apr 11, 2018; surgeon260 Sergeant. button rifled is a long-standing debate in the shooting world, and it is beyond the scope of this article. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Sep 19, 2010 · Smallest recent 100 yd agg this year with a Shilen 6groove 22ppc 14 twist . Bartlein. Bartlein has the gain twist and left hand stuff cornered. Feb 9, 2018 · With Barrel mfg options like Bartlein, Brux, Hawk Hill, Krieger, Rock Creek, Proof research and Mullerworks how can you go wrong. com – Stocks Bartlein; Cut Rifling vs. Rifle Barrel Makers Mar 13, 2013 · The custom 22lr barrel for my CZ 455 is finally done. What I mean by that is take two theoretical identical barrels both made by Krieger, Bartlein, Proof Research, Benchmark, Shilen, Brux, Rock Creek, Hawk Hill, Criterion, etc I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". The throat erosion and copper fouling were awful in this barrel, and I didn't even run it hard. 5" at 100 meter when replaced at the beginning of his life he was giving approx 0. If you get the Shilen, get a ratchet. He says that the Shilen, Douglas and Lilja barrels can be a crap shoot if it is a good one or not. 260 and 6. 820" or 0. Criterion is a Krieger with a faster manufacturing process, and arguably better longevity. 204 Ruger Guns: Rem 700 sps varmint Location: Central Minnesota Jul 22, 2014 · Part two of the multi part interview with Bartlein BarrelsSniper's Hide Online Video Visit www. Now the question is this: is this because of fad or because of smaller aggs? A quick look at the match scores (for group) indicated that smaller aggs may not be the case. They are both fantastic shooters! I would say it would be a flip of the coin between those two. Any input good or bad on either would be appreciated Jun 19, 2009 · Of the three I'ld pick Rock. The newer ones have the 0. I like Krieger, but have moved to Bartlein. 9 percent of the people I've heard from. Lilja's are button-rifled barrels vs the cut-rifled Krieger & Bartlein if that matters to you. Not 5R that I recall. I ordered one last year simply because of the lead times on when I needed it. May 30, 2024 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". Decide based on wait times. And those are push button barrels! Right now Bartlein and Krieger own the benchrest market. My top 2 pics are Hart and Krieger. Have them on a 22 LR, just ordered a 22 cal 29" 8 twist heavy varmint for a 223 build yesterday, 264 Win Mag, 7-300 Win Mag, and two 300 Win Mags. Other Krieger's have been good and normal velocity. That goes for both 4 groove and 5R rifling. For more money they offer the Krieger cut-rifled blank or a Shilen ratchet-rifled blank which they chamber, profile, drill gas ports, and crown. Cool test BTW. A May 21, 2015 · Dan Lilja makes great barrels but it's hard to beat what Frank White can do with a Krieger or Barty blank. This may well be because the Krieger is on a BAT action and the Bartlein on a B78. I've had others in the past, including MGM (preferred bbl blanks before they were a thing - those were not consistent for me). - However, recently the precision crowd seem Feb 18, 2023 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". All chambered by the same gun smith. 0". 5 twists are all we ever shot on our ARs was the best tube out there at the time for the 90s Jun 14, 2016 · Bartlein Barrels Benchmark Barrels Hawk Hill Customs Krieger Barrels Lilja Barrels Shilen Barrels Other? June 14, 2016, 12:48 AM #2: turtlehead Oct 20, 2021 · Barrels are one of the cheapest parts of the build yet one of the most important. Well a few years ago I noticed trouble getting some of my 6mm BR format rifles to shoot as well as I expected. I've got it all ready just need a barrel, I know what caliber I want (284) but to be honest I've never heard of a criterion at all. In fact, just a few years ago, Shilen was the darling of the group shooters. I used Krieger mostly for years. They are still great barrels IMHO. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Aug 20, 2023 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". I know, they are all premium barrels, but just curious if you have Feb 19, 2021 · Either barrel being considered should be sub 1/2 MOA. My Bartlein, Krieger and Brux barrels are shooters. It sounds like I may need to do a lot more research. The Navy also found Kreiger's slow in their Mk 12 testing. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Mar 23, 2017 · For cut barrels in no order: Bartlein, Brux, and Krieger For button I tend to use Hart, Lilja, and some McGowen Reactions: Winshortmag , walkinhorseman , wvbuckbuster and 5 others Mar 9, 2018 · I've shot Krieger, Hart, Obermeyer, Blackstar (remember those? They were HARD) and Douglas in service rifle M14s, have a 22" Krieger in 308 from @MikeRTacOps, shot a couple John Holliger PacNor 1:6. I still have one sitting in my safe next to a Shilen I will use to rebuild the same 300 win. Any thoughts are much appreciated! Apr 26, 2011 · Re: Shilen accuracy: Select Match Grade vs Match Grade My smith won't use anything but Rock, Pac Nor, or Bartlein. Apr 11 Sep 8, 2023 · When I ordered my Vudoo V22S they had Krieger, Bartlein, Benchmark and Shilen blanks in stock. 830" at 26", depending on the age of the rifle. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Two things I see immediately: one: The B dimension for the Palma never exceeds 2. Prices run from about $250 to $600. Jan 8, 2017 · I have been torn between going with the cheaper LaRue or the more expensive Bartlein or Krieger. My first Hart . The one main thing is the way they cut the crown. The octagons are good too, but the best ones are taper lapped by a select few guys out there. Sep 12, 2023 · I'm not saying anything bad about Shilen. May 3, 2010 · The instructor said he eventually lost the contract because of the volume of barrels needed. I also have a kreiger that I put on a 220 swift build. Whether you are re-barreling your service rifle, AR, benchrest, F-class or hunting rifle, Krieger Barrels gives you the freedom to customize. Case prep and ammo has been the same. Something like a survey for… Aug 23, 2009 · I am sure Paul Craddock is as well, but put many months in your timeline, or buy a Criterion or Lilja barrel that is pre fitted for what you want. May 26, 2016 · I had a Shilen 6. Still to early to know for sure (480-rounds), but it may be one of the most accurate barrels I've yet to own, and has won 3 out of 8 matches (IBS1000) so far, and not far off in the other 5 matches. Bartlein owners use to work for Krieger. May 19, 2013 · How is the Rainier ultra match vs a CLE Bartlein or Krieger? Just curious. snipershi Apr 25, 2020 · I have used Douglas, Hart, Pac Nor, Kreiger,Lilja and Shilen an have a Bartlein on order. So what? Dec 4, 2008 · +1 for the shilen select match. i believe krieger was/is the same. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Sep 22, 2008 · I'm not so sure about Rock barrels anymore. Mar 10, 2020 · For example, Krieger offers both . If I was told that I couldn't have a Shilen, but a Krieger was available (or a Bartlein for that matter), I wouldn't hesitate. Button Rifling May 19, 2018 · I'm far from unhappy with the results in four Kriegers, three Shilen ratchet rifled, one each Benchmark & Lilja titebore - but am curious about whether there are subtle advantages to using different reamers in cut-rifled vs button-rifled blanks, like the Krieger vs Shilen? Nov 24, 2013 · With the exception of my shilen opening up after a few rounds due to its light weight (hunting rifle), it damn near keeps up with my krieger mtu, even at 2" shorter (at 400 yds). He said that things have changed for these makers over the last 20 years. Contrary to that theory, I don't see carbon accumulate there. Cut Rifling vs. May 2, 2018 · My Krieger AR barrels were the slow ones. Nov 19, 2011 · George Gardner likes Bartlein barrels. Obviously it still shoots nice, tight groups in its current state, but I do a good bit of long range target shooting and it definitely likes hot handloads with heavy bullets. 2571 agg with a Shilen 22ppc 1-13. Hart, Broughton and Krieger. There may be other minor variances among manufacturers. Switched to Bartlein. cale I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". As always, Apache does exceptional work, at least for 99. A quality barrel manufacturer makes quality barrels. 28-0. No complaints but I've not shot it for groups. 20" Bartlein M24 Muzzle Threaded 1/2-28 (0. 1:13 twist. 17- to 0. At 100 yds I was always below 1/2". Here is why I am asking: - kicking off a custom build - Historically, have seen Kreiger portrayed as the gold standard of cut rifled barrels. Krieger Bartlein Broughton Lothar Walther Border (cut rifled) - I really would love to try more of these, but the UK AW barrels are pretty damn impressive I have been very let down by the products coming out of Shilen the last several years or so YMMV. Dec 22, 2008 · 1-Tie between Bartlein and Krieger 2-Lilja 3-Hart 4-Shilen I have used Bartlein, Krieger and Lilja. My latest barrels are a Bartlein 5C and a Krieger 5R barrel. Minuteman. I had the shilen set back and rechambered by the same smith that did the barlein barrels. I have and have owned rifles with Bartlein, Krieger and Shilen. 223 bull barrel and Savage target action from NSS. John Krieger Interview with AccurateShooter at SHOT Show: Feb 15, 2015 · According to Pac-Nor site their Super Match SS barrel is $310. Not sure how much of that is just the chambering, but ultimately I would go for the Shilen. If this is something you can replace barrels on at home, sure give it a go. If I felt the need for that level of accuracy potential in a 10/22, I wouldn't hesitate to but a Bartlein barrel. How much heavier are you planning to go and what will it be used for? Krieger Bartlein I am considering my next barrel. ) Button vs. To me, (as I learned from you) on the #9 profile this allows for more material around the chamber for large calibers, more bedding support under the barrel immediately in front of the action, and also allows material for a future set back. If you take Douglas barrel and all the add on options your paying pretty close to a Kreiger barrel. Then comes more makers barrel out of curiosity. Those are the one I have currently besides factory barrels. What about the Vudoo? Feb 10, 2022 · IF you want a new build and a new gun, get a Shilen or Muller. Until the last few years, we just got some new makers. I'd rather spend the extra $100-$150 for a premium barrel than take my chances with one that may or may not be. Kreiger/Bartlein only offer one type barrel so not offering different grades of barrels. Dec 27, 2017 · I've had real good luck with Krieger and Lilja. www. Dec 20, 2019 · Howdy all, trying to decide between the two barrel brands at Northland for a savage gun I'm building. My GAP rifle had a Rock Creek, so when I needed barrels I went with them, Then I had alway heard good things about Shilen and went with a couple of those. Price and availability make them desirable to me, especially after waiting 5 months for my krieger. Bartlein test though. I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". Here's a couple of pics just because. I wrote to WOA about their barrels. Shilen gets talked about and has some fans for sure but I figure its kind of a roll of the dice anyways. Mar 28, 2015 · savageboy23 Senior Member Posts: 261 Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2012 1:03 am. Leaning Feb 7, 2011 · Re: difference between bartlein and ER shaw Generally speaking, Bartlein barrels are considered top tier barrels and ER Shaw are high mid grade. the Krieger has yet to be chambered and threadedbut gross visual inspection looks good. Cheers. 1737 agg 200yd a . Always willing to try new things. Feb 11, 2024 · I prefer Bartlein myself. After doing a lot of reading on the various forums, I have come to the conclusion that the LaRue is considered one of the most accurate of the cheaper barrels (especially while they are on sale) while the Bartlein or Krieger are considered two of Jan 10, 2020 · If you look at most equipment lists of the top scoring competitors at most national level competitions, probably 50-75% are using Bartlein barrels. 25 moa or better if I do my part. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Mar 11, 2016 · I have never not been able to get a #2 or #3 krieger or shilen to shoot to real fine hunting gun standards and most are better than normal. Full Member. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Bartlein's are cut rifled and Shilen's are button rifle respectfully, you need to compare apples to apples. Bartlein/Krieger. Not necessarily in that order, and I really don't prefer one over the other. Whether you would like to choose from one of our standard Sporter, Match Taper, Palma profile or straight contours, or if you would like to copy your existing barrel's profile or Feb 19, 2014 · Hard to go wrong with a Bartlein, Krieger, Brux or Rock cut rifle in contour and twist desired, and go w/ a reputable smith. Feb 22, 2021 · When building a PRS style rifle in 6BRX should I get a McGowan, Shilen, or Xcaliber barrel. Planning to finish it at 24". Because they have more slope to the land sides, carbon is said to accumulate there less. 458-caliber, in stainless or chrome moly, and in a wide array of chamberings and contours. Apr 12, 2018 · Proof vs. As one of the posters above stated, the 5. Good LuckPlanning the projects is half the fun! Not trying to poke at Benchmark, Hart, Shilen etc What we have found along with a host of other shooters etcis that the consistency from barrel to barrel with twist uniformity etcis better with the cut than with the button for reasons stated by 264charlie. Krieger Barrels offers a wide variety of both standard and custom barrel contours for bolt action rifles as well as AR10, AR15, M1 Garand, M1A/M14 and service rifles. It is twisted 1/12. Re: KREIGER Barrels VS HART Barrels They are both great quality barrels and there are many other barrel makers as well that produce great barrels like Shilen,Rock creek and the list goes on. Krieger also does AR barrels. ShootSmallGroups. I would say they were in this order of how they shot: Krieger/Bartlein Benchmark/Green Mountain Lilja The Krieger and Bartlein shot about the same with the Krieger edging out the Bartlein on that day with that ammo slightly at Wanted to let you know that I set another service national record with my current Bartlein. Shilen barrels are available from 0. James May 19, 2020 · I keep saying this with each barrel, but more so now then ever, I cannot wait to shoot this Bartlein at 100yds!! Since everyone always asks, this Bartlein is the same exact barrel specs as all the others tested. A lighter weight contour when the barrel gets button rifled (Bartlein Barrels only does single point cut rifling) the stress being put into the blank is much greater. And I am thinking about using Bartlein this time. Reactions: King_beardsly and 1813Benny. Mar 2, 2019 · Bartlein, Krieger and Hawk Hill have all been good barrels. They were shooters, too. Doesn't the smith have to lob some off of chamber end to get desired shank length? Anyone know what the muzzle diameter will be on this @ 24". Krieger's numbers are what I was going off of, but Bartlein and Shilen were other considerations. Oct 22, 2017 · As has been said before, if you choose a barrel from one of the top manufactures they are all pretty much the same if you ask me. I would wait for the Shilen, with Benchmark as my second choice. I have years of test data for 6BR and 223rem on my server to compare and see how they stack up. “Why worry about a little barrel fouling when the throat is subjected to a brutal 5,600° F volcano at 55,000 PSI? The CM was a booger to break in, but puts 190 SMKs into bitty groups with its 10 twist. The rifle is a Rem 700 with a Jewel trigger. I would start with specs then go from there. Oct 5, 2004 · Re: Shilen Vs. I know bartlein is in a different league, and both shoot incredible . 650 @26". I have used a few different manufacturers over the years Bartlein, Shilen, Carbon 6, Broughton , and Proof research. If you are going to pay for a select shilen or ultra dougy then you are in the price range of a kreiger or rock creek and I would take one of those over shilen or douglas. 's; one with a Krieger 4 groove and one with a Bartlein 5r. I bought the Broughton as a blank and fit it to the action and it shot like a dream. Of the two options go Kreiger, other great options are Benchmark & Shilen ratchet barrels. 5 twist There is no BEST but I believe Krieger (cut barrels) Shilen (button) are both VERY consistent in turning out QUALITY year after year. If the choice was mine I would hands down go with Bartlein Dec 3, 2020 · Yes I should have mentioned what brands I am looking at. Stainless Select Match from the Barrelman, was shipped in a reasonalbe time frame. I have one Shilen in a 35 Whelen. Reactions: Jamie D Van Roekel and CZDiesel Mar 26, 2022 · In my 223rem Tl3 barrel review and testing, the MW shot the best of all of them (Bartlein, Krieger, MW, Shilen, Benchmark) Reactions: 1791PrecisionArmory , powdahound76 , Terry Cross and 5 others Dec 17, 2009 · I had a Kreiger SS 1/10 twist barrel 30-06 and it was better than 1/2" group rifle. They all shoot extremely well. 300 win mag in about 2 months that I've had it. Dude who ran Krieger decided to make barrels faster, made a separate company. The 2 barrels I’m torn between are brux and ace. Remington Factory ? I really like Shilen barrels I had one with #7 contour on my remington and it lasted 11,948 rounds giving at the end 1. 236 and . I'm sure Bighorn wouldn't have tailored their action to the capability if those barrels don't perform. 62 gas guns, we use Bartlein and Criterion blanks. They were also very nice when i ordered a barrel and delivery was under ETA. Bugholes as 30 cal Bartlein blanks in stock so the lead time shouldn't be a factor. Read a post not to long ago about this and everyone picked bartlein because of their modern machining ( using cnc's to do gain twist and such); Secondly people picked bartlein because they do alot to support the sport in terms of table prized and support for competitions. I sold that 40X, but always wondered if the Benchmark didn't get a fair shake with that reamer issue. just pulling it and trying a different barrel. 5x47 have had 2-3 kriegers all were great 260 and 6. May 1, 2015 · I have 250 rounds down the factory barrel on my 110 FCP . 224 8 twist SS 4R #3 27". The upper crust barrels offered like Douglas's double air gauge, or Shilen's select match, as far as them being worth more money, that only you can decide by the buyer, in my Nov 30, 2014 · Been down this road more than a few times, thats why most of my rifles wear a Krieger,Bartlein or Shilen 3 groove in . They offer a nice package of barrel / bolt combination for AR's. I did notice the cylinder section at the breech of the Palma Contours varied some for the Krieger barrels (Krieger’s was 1/2″ shorter than what is shown here). Mar 5, 2015 · Originally Posted by bonefishI just ordered a #3 Bartlein today. Put one on a 340 weatherby that I built. 219 bore, cut rifled 4 groove. I have had three good ones and three stinkers. They are not made from real match grade blanks like Douglas, Krieger, Bartlein, Hart or Lilja but they can be very accurate and better than any DD, Spikes, Faxon, BA, Seekins or Green Mountain barrel we have tested. Criterion doesn’t offer BRX. In fact, Matthew Brousseau won the PRS for the second year in a row, and he was using a Krieger barrel. 35" at 100 Meter I would have taken one even now if it was possible for me. I would be interested in a Criterion vs. So are we saying forget these new profiles and run with cut rifling,or the fad actually has merit? Jan 3, 2014 · BugHoles. My opinion is stuck between Broughton and Proof Research. Get whatever one you can get your hands on the quickest. Jul 21, 2023 · What are the optimal specifications of the barrel? Length? A 1-12" or a 1-16" twist rate? (One of the ballistics gurus I emailed prefers a 1-12". com Jan 1, 2024 · Any of those should provide better accuracy over the factory barrel. May 14, 2016 · So if I'm reading you right you're saying bartlein and krieger are on par with each other so far and the shilen were great but required more cleaning vs the other 2. I'm planning to buy a pre-fit from Southern Precision Rifles in 6mm Creedmoor. Krieger is another brand that has been on this list of barrels that the pros have used year after year, all the way back to the inception of the PRS. I personaly believe the person chambering and crowning the barrel will be more of a factor than brand name. Douglas, shilen, rock, Krieger, hs precision, and a few others were the choices. You can find arguments on either side and the difference is close enough that people really can't tell just from owning them. com – Stocks Bartlein, Krieger, Brux, Rock Creek, Obermeyer, and MullerWorks; BrunoShooters. - However, recently the precision crowd seem I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". A Shaw is $220. 830". I have never tried any carbon fiber wrapped barrels and probably won't, not because they don't work, but because I'm more of a tradionalist. If you shoot more than 3 shot groups youre not in the hunting gun game anymore and need bigger tubes I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". Shilen and Muller barrels are the two most popular barrels in the ARA/PSL Unlimited class. Usually with Kreiger an Hart they only make one grade of barrels where Douglas and Shilen an a few others make different grades. Going 26 inch heavy varmint 1:8. You can pick any of the above, and others too, and be happy for years. Sep 2, 2021 · Lilja and Krieger seem to always be mentioned in the same breath during discussions of the best barrels for custom builds, with Bartlein, Douglas, and Shilen close seconds. As for stainless vs chromoly, the wear life is not that different. The art form is at its zenith right now. Every barrel is unique, even from the best. Mullerworks 224 12 twist SS Remington Varmint 27" Dec 18, 2023 · I've owned several button barrels and a few cut rifled barrels from K&P, Bartlein, Brux and Krieger. Dec 4, 2017 · The Sendero has a muzzle diameter of 0. Dec 5, 2017 · I screwed an ER Shaw onto a Savage 110 a few years back. Nov 15, 2019 · The best 5 shot group at 100 yards with the Krieger I was able to get so far was this one using Berger 77 OTM bullets: Best 5 shots at 100 yards with the Bartlein so far with Berger 77 OTM bullets: Just recently got a Shilen 1 in 7 . - However, recently the precision crowd seem Mar 10, 2012 · Several things go into an accurate barrel-- MOST of the work that matters is done by whoever rifles the bar stock. 400" Long) 22LR Match Eachus Dec 5, 2017 · Personally, have used Shilen, Hart and Bartlein from the US, and a couple from Australia. Jun 12, 2018 · Lilja can make an excellent rimfire barrel but from my experience that's the exception vs the rule. So you have the same original ethos for quality that carries over from legit competition grade barrels (Krieger is on par with Bartlein, Lilja, Douglas, etc) Javascript is required. I decide to change twist so that 30-06 I put a Bartlein 5r 1/11 twist then for back up put Lilja 1/11 twist also chamber for the 30-06 using same reamer I got those rifles in 2008. 224 6. 308 and it was absolutely perfect laser beam had one shilen match (have another 6mm blank waiting) but that was another laser beam . The contours shown are for Bartlein barrels. 5-06 barrel and that thing went South after about 1000 rounds or so. Jul 2, 2013 · I have several Bartlein 5R barrels and don't think they clean easier than a Krieger or Brux four groove. What Pattern. I have a bartlein on a 338 that shoots half moa or less consistently. Apr 20, 2024 · Krieger Barrels is the 3 rd most popular brand, representing 10% of these pros. Krieger and Bartlein are both part of the best of the best barrel makers. The Lilja barrels I've used in 6. Says is . Jan 21, 2020 · on my third bartlein all have been great . Continue reading Jun 18, 2007 · I also have 2 custom chambered bartleins. 260 Javascript is required. Both offer 5R, but it will cost you on the Krieger and equalize the prices between them. Jul 26, 2022 · I'm curious on what everyone feels is the best barrel manufacturer. Mar 12, 2025 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often Dec 1, 2022 · Wilson Combat barrels are advertised as match grade but are made by ER Shaw. Krieger, Lilja, Shilen, and Pac Nor top my list. com Or chat in our forum at http://forum. However, Bartlein and Krieger are hands down the best barrels out there. Visit my website for hardware and software that will help you achieve your competitive goals. I would not shy away from a Rock Creek barrel. I. Terry Cross uses Krieger. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Aug 22, 2012 · 65BR - Howdy ! There's an embarassement of riches, as regards barrel choices for today's shooters. Krieger have typically run the fastest per caliber for me, but Bartlein and Hawk Hill have always been good barrels. Krieger’s single-point cut-rifled barrels are Mar 27, 2018 · Im going to re-barrel a rifle in 264 win mag, and was wondering if there’s any preference for a Bartlein vs Brux barrel? Going with a 3B/#5 respectively and a 1/8 twist for 140gr bullets. CM or SS Flutes. The rainier is in the same price range as the CLE but below the Keystone. Ordering a Krieger or other non prefit gets too expensive with the gunsmith charges. Aug 27, 2013 · I have 2 Shilen 224cal in the Ratchet groove, bot are chambered in 222 rem and shoot extremely well, as good an any others,( Brux, Bartlein and Kreiger )that I have. That says a lot. All things being equal. Krieger is great of course as is Brux. Krieger barrels on several R700 bolt guns in . snipershide. It doesn't really matter which you purchase. Please enable javascript before you are allowed to see this page. Excellent results with all. The current one only below 1/2" half the time. The first one shot better. Have been very happy with all, but my all time hands down best barrel maker that I use is Bartlein. 237 barrels in 6mm. Bore looks smoother. Barrel makers must be feeling a crunch right now, especially for rimfire Jul 12, 2013 · I have owned, Douglas, Brux, Krieger, Bartline, Hart, Shilen, and Criterion. Both Craddock and Compass Lake use top of the line blanks: Krieger, Bartlein, Douglas, Criterion (for the most part). They have all been winners. Feb 19, 2014 · Hard to go wrong with a Bartlein, Krieger, Brux or Rock cut rifle in contour and twist desired, and go w/ a reputable smith. Oct 17, 2013 · I have two 30/375 S. Or a Lilja or Krieger barrel, for that matter. They buy rifled blanks from Wilson, Shilen, and Krieger. Oct 21, 2013 · I never tested a Shilen in this round up review as you stated above. In the future, I'm sticking with better known, more established barrel manufacturers. It shoots 155 NCCs like lazer beams. I have barrels from Brux, Krieger, Bartlein, Broughton, Lilja, Obermeyer, Shilen, and Hawk Hill. Today I think Krieger is probably the top of the tier 1s with Bartlein right there as well. , Kreiger barrel is $325. or canted? Gain twist? Bartlein and Rock are pioneering this? Contour? you wont get a sporter weight stainless Krieger Dec 12, 2020 · I have heard a mix bag of reviews on the McGowen barrels. The known top shelf barrels like Bartlein, Krieger, and Hart range in price from $330-$375. That included two of the top 10 finishers in the PRS and 1 of the top 10 shooters in the NRL. Ratchet vs other types of rifling - pros and cons? 3. So again, a big thank you to Frank/Bartlein. I think I fired ~100 rounds through it, before it pulled it for a Shilen. 308. The shilen seems higher quality to me. 5r. Shilen improved 1/4 moa. Both are good shooters but the Krieger is better. Krieger has been delivering blanks way way faster, like 1/3 the time. Feb 19, 2021 · Equal straightness, equal finish, equal bore tolerances. One comment made about so what Bartlein and Krieger own benchrest etc Apr 17, 2020 · It always shot ok, but several Kriegers, a Lilja titebore, one Bartlein, and a couple of Shilen ratchet rifled bbls were as good or better with SK, Lapua, and Eley ammo. It sounds like it may just boil down to a Shilen vs. Thank you for making such great, consistent barrels . Aug 1, 2021 · 1. Dec 26, 2023 · I’m going to order a new barrel for a Remington 700 243 soon. My third 30-06 with Shilen I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". Dec 27, 2021 · Bartlein Krieger Lilja Shilen Pac-Nor Hart Broughton Brux Douglas Schneider Rock Creek Lothar-Walther are all capable of manufacturing world class barrels. Both clean up very well and the Krieger is 25' faster, but again, has a melonited barrel. Big THANK YOU to Frank @ Bartlein barrels for donating this barrel and continuing to support the SH community!! Every review or testing the SH community wants to see, Frank is always quick to say no problem Ill get a barrel out to you. I've shot some really really good groups from both button and cut barrels. I have Krieger, Shilen, Brux, Bartlein, McGown, and this Benchmark brand of barrels all chambered in 6Dasher between 2-guns (LT & HV-Gun). No particular reason other than I hear raves about Bartlein and they are doing well in shortrange benchrest. It is for 20 shots @ 1000 yards, I shot a 200-9X. Have both the CLE Bartlein and Krieger also a Keystone Bartlein. Button Rifling. 2266agg with a 6ppc Krieger 14 twist Standing best 2 gun 2006 . Sep 20, 2023 · I prefer Bartlein, Krieger, and Brux. The stainless is in a MCMillan M40 A1 stock in forest camo and is my favorite rifle. I can source shilen barrels from my supplier however I think he can order bartlein. Apr 8, 2016 · Criterion, Bartlien, Krieger, Shilen, McGowan. As you turn the contour smaller and smaller in size this can have a negative effect on the bore sizes changing and opening up. I shoot 22-250 currently with my second Lilja barrel. Jan 26, 2014 694 635 Colorado. Like my 3 Rock Creeks, 2 Shilen MS, 2 Kriegers. It shot ok, but not great; it wasn't worth the additional time/ammo in developing a handload vs. Nov 27, 2024 · In this article, Chip shares the knowledge of a dozen experts including respected barrel-makers Frank Green (Bartlein Barrels), John Krieger (Krieger Barrels), Dan Lilja (Lilja Barrels), and Tim North (Broughton Barrels). 5 twist. 7" Krieger AR service rifles, have a couple Tooley Bartleins for my AIAX, a Kreiger 300wm from RW Snyder. Out of them all there isn't a nickels worth of difference in them, they all shoot great. Nov 14, 2014 · The contours shown are for Bartlein barrels. What about Bartlein or Brux? RE: Actions 2500X, Turbo, and X3L are the usual suspects with the ARA. 56 needs all the velocity it can get to give energy transfer and bullet expansion. If you want top tier accuracy, you'll need to spend quite a bit more on a barrel from Krieger, Bartlein, Lilja, or Proof Research Aug 20, 2023 · I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". - However, recently the precision crowd seem Jun 6, 2019 · Then he will seek out his second choice that he was going to use in the first place. Then, on the Bartlein side, I see offerings of 99% (or more) 5R barrels. I have used more Bartleins than anything especially considering the Impact by Stuteville barrels are all Bartlein. Hart has several options grooves? 3,4,5,6? Standard vs. ive only shot 10 votes, 27 comments. Their "house brand" barrels are Wilson Arms match grade, lapped, and button rifled. For our work on 7. When I rebarrel my hunting rifle, it'll probably be with another From 20 caliber to Four Bore, Krieger Barrels offers a wide variety of popular and rare calibers in bolt action, AR-15, AR-10, M1 Garand, M1A/M14 and M1903. But as important as barrel quality is the chamber job. Cut rifled vs. Nov 4, 2017 · Brux, Broughton, Krieger, Pac-Nor, Shilen, Lilja, Noveske and Bartlein are all top tier, expensive and may or may not shoot any better. There are so many good ones that it's hard to narrow it down to just one. 224" cal SS 24" 5-groove 1-14 was great ! I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". Barrels are flawless. I have found that they all make good barrels but sometimes you can get a turd. Javascript is required. Aug 18, 2021 · 25 to 30 years ago I would have said Douglas or Shilen as I had a couple of customs built in the 90s with them that shot lights out. Lots of them. There should be some kind of way that we can get a consensus ranking of the barrel manufacturers. com – Stocks Krieger, Shilen, Hart, and Brux; Grizzly. One of the top 10 shooters was using a Krieger barrel. Cut? Shilen and Muller are common in the ARA. Dec 25, 2023 · Thats why Ill be testing a 6mm and 224 ACE blank to compare to my large qty of barrels from Krieger, Mullerworks, Bartlein, Hawk Hill, Osprey, Wilson and Green Mountain in the safe. My experience has been the cut rifled barrels are easier to find a load for and also tend to shoot multiple bullets/loads better across the board than button barrels do. I chose the Shilen Ratchet barrel and I'm very very happy with my choice. Thanks Ya, I totally agree. In this article, Chip shares the knowledge of a dozen experts including respected barrel-makers Frank Green (Bartlein Barrels), John Krieger (Krieger Barrels), Dan Lilja (Lilja Barrels), and Tim North (Broughton Barrels). WAY easier to clean. qheg ejcpjq gxmy ycht meiqys anlpcz qmhlgm ogk jmbxn teyuk qfboz xoekx vzjca jqgvx xsopoa